Aren't Comdata and EFS the same company?

Same parent (Corpay, formerly FLEETCOR), different brands. They share network but maintain separate product, sales, and support organizations. Comdata is positioned as the broader fleet platform; EFS retains its legacy IFTA-focused position.

Which has better discounts?

Depends on volume and chain. Comdata's published discounts are slightly less aggressive at Pilot Flying J than the Apex TCS card; EFS's volume-tier discounts can beat Comdata at high volume. Run actual gallons through both.

Which is easier for owner-operators?

Neither, really — both target fleet onboarding. Owner-operators usually find AtoB, RTS, or TCS friendlier.

Can I migrate from EFS to Comdata?

Yes — Corpay supports internal migrations between brands. Discount tiers and account fees may shift, so model the changeover before committing.

Are per-card controls the same on both?

Similar but Comdata leads on depth (time-of-day, item-level, per-driver limits). EFS covers the basics; Comdata covers the basics plus enterprise-grade granularity.

Comdata vs EFS Fleet Card — Fuel Cards Comparison

Comdata and EFS are both owned by FLEETCOR (now Corpay) and share much of the same truck-stop network. The branded experience and product depth differ — Comdata leads on per-card controls and the largest combined network; EFS leads on legacy IFTA reporting depth and integration with traditional TMS systems.

Editorial estimates — verify rates with providers.

Side-by-side

	Comdata	EFS Fleet Card
Tagline	Largest US fleet-card network with deepest per-card controls.	Legacy fleet card with deep IFTA tools and Comdata-network integration.
Discount per gallon	$0.05 - $0.30 at preferred stops	Variable, volume-tier dependent
Network size	100,000+ truck stops and travel centers	Comdata-network truck stops + EFS direct
Billing	Weekly statements, ACH or wire	Weekly statements, ACH
Best for	Mid-size to large fleets needing granular controls	Mid-size fleets prioritizing IFTA depth

Comdata

Largest US fleet-card network with deepest per-card controls.

Pros

Largest combined truck-stop network
Granular per-card controls (per-gallon, per-day, time-of-day)
Comdata Smart Card for non-fuel purchases
Strong fleet-grade reporting

Cons

Onboarding aimed at 5+ truck operations
Higher monthly fees than newer entrants for small fleets
Mobile UX less polished than AtoB

EFS Fleet Card

Legacy fleet card with deep IFTA tools and Comdata-network integration.

Pros

Deep IFTA reporting integrations
Long operational history and stability
Comdata-network access
Strong TMS integrations

Cons

Per-card controls less granular than Comdata
Mobile experience dated
Owner-operator onboarding slower

Which should you choose?

Comdata and EFS share so much infrastructure that the choice often comes down to which sales rep wins the relationship and which control surface the fleet prefers. Comdata leads on per-card controls and modern reporting; EFS leads on IFTA depth and TMS integration with legacy systems. Both are FLEETCOR brands — economics negotiate similarly.

Get quotes from both providers

Submit one profile and we'll match you with Comdata, EFS Fleet Card, and other vetted fuel cards providers.

FAQs

Aren't Comdata and EFS the same company?: Same parent (Corpay, formerly FLEETCOR), different brands. They share network but maintain separate product, sales, and support organizations. Comdata is positioned as the broader fleet platform; EFS retains its legacy IFTA-focused position.
Which has better discounts?: Depends on volume and chain. Comdata's published discounts are slightly less aggressive at Pilot Flying J than the Apex TCS card; EFS's volume-tier discounts can beat Comdata at high volume. Run actual gallons through both.
Which is easier for owner-operators?: Neither, really — both target fleet onboarding. Owner-operators usually find AtoB, RTS, or TCS friendlier.
Can I migrate from EFS to Comdata?: Yes — Corpay supports internal migrations between brands. Discount tiers and account fees may shift, so model the changeover before committing.
Are per-card controls the same on both?: Similar but Comdata leads on depth (time-of-day, item-level, per-driver limits). EFS covers the basics; Comdata covers the basics plus enterprise-grade granularity.