Are AtoB's flat-rate discounts actually better?

Easier to predict — yes. Absolute number — depends on chain and volume. At Love's, AtoB often beats Comdata; at Pilot, TCS (Apex's card) and Comdata are often comparable to AtoB.

Can a single-truck owner-operator get a Comdata card?

Yes, but Comdata's onboarding and pricing favor larger operations. Most single-truck owner-operators find AtoB, RTS, or TCS friendlier and cheaper at the lower volume tier.

Does Comdata cover non-fuel purchases?

Yes — the Comdata Smart Card extends to maintenance, lodging, and other categories with per-card controls. AtoB stays focused on fuel and limited DEF/oil.

How does network coverage compare?

Comdata is larger. AtoB covers the major truck-stop chains and falls back to Mastercard acceptance at non-network stations — which can be useful but at worse per-gallon discount.

Which has the better app?

AtoB. The mobile-first product is significantly more polished than Comdata's app, which feels like a layered add-on to a legacy product.

AtoB vs Comdata — Fuel Cards Comparison

AtoB is the modern challenger — flat-rate discounts, mobile-first UX, owner-operator-friendly onboarding. Comdata is the legacy incumbent (Corpay-owned) with the largest US network and the deepest per-card spend controls. The right fit depends on fleet size and what matters more: clean UX or fleet-grade controls.

Editorial estimates — verify rates with providers.

Side-by-side

	AtoB	Comdata
Tagline	Modern fleet card with transparent pricing and owner-operator-friendly UX.	Largest US fleet-card network with deepest per-card controls.
Discount per gallon	$0.05 - $0.25 flat rate	$0.05 - $0.30 at preferred stops
Network size	Major truck stops + Mastercard fallback	100,000+ truck stops and travel centers
Billing	Weekly ACH	Weekly statements, ACH or wire
Best for	Owner-operators and small fleets wanting clean UX	Mid-size to large fleets

AtoB

Modern fleet card with transparent pricing and owner-operator-friendly UX.

Pros

Transparent flat-rate per-gallon discounts
Mobile-first app with real-time transaction views
Easy onboarding for owner-operators
No long-term contracts

Cons

Smaller network than Comdata at the largest truck stops
Per-card controls less granular than Comdata
Newer player with shorter operational history

Comdata

Largest US fleet-card network with deepest per-card controls.

Pros

Largest combined truck-stop network
Granular per-card controls
Smart Card for non-fuel purchases
Strong enterprise reporting

Cons

Onboarding aimed at fleets, not owner-operators
Higher account fees for small fleets
Mobile UX dated

Which should you choose?

AtoB wins for owner-operators and small fleets (under 5 trucks) who value transparent pricing and modern UX. Comdata wins for mid-size and large fleets (5+ trucks) where granular controls and the broadest network matter more than the experience layer. Both have credible discounts; the operational fit determines which actually saves more money.

Get quotes from both providers

Submit one profile and we'll match you with AtoB, Comdata, and other vetted fuel cards providers.

FAQs

Are AtoB's flat-rate discounts actually better?: Easier to predict — yes. Absolute number — depends on chain and volume. At Love's, AtoB often beats Comdata; at Pilot, TCS (Apex's card) and Comdata are often comparable to AtoB.
Can a single-truck owner-operator get a Comdata card?: Yes, but Comdata's onboarding and pricing favor larger operations. Most single-truck owner-operators find AtoB, RTS, or TCS friendlier and cheaper at the lower volume tier.
Does Comdata cover non-fuel purchases?: Yes — the Comdata Smart Card extends to maintenance, lodging, and other categories with per-card controls. AtoB stays focused on fuel and limited DEF/oil.
How does network coverage compare?: Comdata is larger. AtoB covers the major truck-stop chains and falls back to Mastercard acceptance at non-network stations — which can be useful but at worse per-gallon discount.
Which has the better app?: AtoB. The mobile-first product is significantly more polished than Comdata's app, which feels like a layered add-on to a legacy product.